Is India’s position in the global dairy sector under threat?

26-11-2020 | |
If other RCEP countries are also eyeing the Indian market, the domestic production will totally collapse, according to an industry expert. Photo: Canva
If other RCEP countries are also eyeing the Indian market, the domestic production will totally collapse, according to an industry expert. Photo: Canva

Due to protests across the country by farmers and trade unions, India has not signed the RCEP – and the dairy industry has had much to do with the government opting out.

In May 2020, India pulled out of the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) with Indonesia, Thailand, Singapore, Malaysia, the Philippines, Vietnam, Myanmar, Brunei, Cambodia, Laos, Australia, China, Japan, New Zealand, and Korea – citing its own India policy.

However, experts believe that the main hurdle came from the dairy sector. India is the world’s largest dairy producer with 187 million tonnes recorded during 2019 and has set a target of 330 Million MT by 2034.

If other RCEP countries are also eyeing the Indian market, the domestic production will totally collapse, according to an industry expert. Photo: Canva

If other RCEP countries are also eyeing the Indian market, the domestic production will totally collapse, according to an industry expert. Photo: Canva

Expert opinion

In order to understand the real reason, we spoke to a dairy expert based in Pune, Maharashtra, who wished not to be named. “With RCEP, milk and milk products from Australia & New Zealand will be dumped in India. After this dumping, procurement of milk from farmers in India will decrease,” the expert said.

Apart from this, India currently has tonnes of skimmed milk which are not yet consumed. I believe the government should not take any decision to join RCEP for a few years. If the government signs this deal, dairy farmers will suffer a lot,”

Even though India is the largest producer and consumer of milk globally, its share in milk exports is a miniscule 172,000 tonnes as per an estimate, as compared to New Zealand, which is a member of RCEP and will become the biggest beneficiary, which currently accounts for 3.5 million tonnes of milk exports.

Global dairy market
Overview of prices for: raw milk, dry whey, skimmed milk powder, cheese and butter

Imports and Exports

As the majority of Indian milk is consumed domestically, companies will import from foreign companies if their prices are lower and as a result, local milk producers will suffer, thereby damaging local dairy farmers’ livelihoods.

In India, over 100 million people are associated with dairy sector destroying this sector by signing a free trade pact would be a decision no government could take. If the government wants to move forward, the dairy sector should be left out of the free trade pact, the expert said.

If other RCEP countries are also eyeing the Indian market, the domestic production will totally collapse and India will become a net importer of dairy products at the cost of Indian milk producers, the expert stressed.

A dairy farmer from Nasik, Rajendra Pawar, said it would be disastrous if India were to sign the RCEP agreement – how can a farmer compete with importers? The dairy traders can flood the market with cheap milk and milk products. Whatever the government says, small dairy farmers and small co-operatives would be wiped out within a few years. The RCEP would destroy our co-operative system in no time, which took us many decades to build.

From tradition to technology – empowering India’s dairy farmers
India is the top milk producer globally and it is also a country where traditional and modern farming practices are very much intertwined. With milk demand in India on the rise there are still many challenges that dairy farmers are facing.

Economist BM Kumaraswamy said that the agreement posed a major threat to the country’s co-operative dairy sector. Over the years, India has built a very social cooperative system that involved small milk producers. The co-operatives are owned by these small producers, and not by companies. In New Zealand, on the other hand, these are owned by companies, and 90% of the milk the country produces is exported.

If milk and milk products are allowed to be imported, this will lead to very tough competition. Milk prices will collapse and this could cause severe harm to our co-operative system of milk production and distribution in the country, Kumaraswamy added.

Unemployment and poverty

The government supporting organisation, Swadeshi Jagran Manch (SJM), has opposed the RCEP agreement and claimed that it would add to unemployment and poverty. Speaking on this development, a source within the Mumbai-based Parsi Dairy Farm said, “The current central government made a wise decision by pulling out of the RCEP agreement, or else it would have pushed many small dairy farms out of business which are catering to tier 1 and tier 2 cities.”

India: Ensuring hygiene standards in the dairy sector
Hygiene and quality of dairy products have become a very important issues after a recent survey report by the Food Safety and Standards Authority of India (FSSAI) found that most of the milk consumed in the country is adulterated.

According to a report on India’s dairy sector, for the next 20 years it would be foolish to allow the import of milk as it would contribute more than 60% of the incremental milk the world will produce in the next 15 years. The overall share of the world milk production will grow to 31% compared to 20% at present from the 14% as of the beginning of 2000.

The report was carried out by the National Dairy Development Board (NDDB) and NITI Aayog, a policy think tank of the Indian government established with the aim to achieve sustainable development.

Global dairy market
Overview of prices for: raw milk, dry whey, skimmed milk powder, cheese and butter

Managing director RS Sodhi of India’s biggest cooperative’s Gujarat Cooperative Milk Marketing Federation Limited (also known as Amul) has also written a letter to Commerce and the industry minister Piyush Goyal, highlighting that “The situation will be unimaginable if the Government of India pursues similar FTAs with EU and grants the USA market access.”

The letter also mentioned New Zealand’s commercial interests and the real reason it’s pushing for the deal, saying that it produces 14 times more than its local domestic requirement and is looking for new markets. India, being the largest consumer of milk in the world, has been its target market for last 2 decades.

The long-term trend analysis conducted by NDDB, Ministry of Agriculture, Niti Aayog, OECD- FAO Dairy Agricultural Outlook 2019-2028 and the International Farm Comparison Network said that India’s dairy growth in production and consumption will continue for the next 2 decades and more, according to Amul Vice-Chairman Jetha Bharawd.

The dairy industry is very important to the Indian rural economy and is the largest contributor to the agricultural Gross Domestic Product. In the 2018-19 Economic Survey it was found that more than 50% of India’s Dairy sector is run by the unorganised sector, meaning local farmers or those involved only in the dairy business.

Indian startup tackles low productivity at dairy farms
In order to check low productivity for dairy farmers, India based Stellapps is providing end-to-end dairy technology solutions to farmers.

In his letter, Maharashtra-based Swabhimani Shetkari Sangathan (SSS) founder Raju Shetti said, “By signing RCEP, India will open its door for cheap dairy imports. If India signs the pact, millions of dairy farmers would be under threat.”

India currently accounts for 20% of world production and for the last 4 years has been growing at a rate of 6.4% annually, against the global growth rate of 1.7%

Shetti also stressed that homegrown brands like Amul, Mahanand, Aarey, Gokul, and others would not be able to match the competitive market and eventually will lose to foreign players.

Kumar
Jagdish Kumar Freelance journalist